Let’s Go To the Hugos: 1984!

The 2014 Hugo Awards ceremony is this Sunday, August 17th at LonCon3. As we count down to the big day, let’s review the best novel nominees from previous decades.

Next up: 30 years ago! (See my previous posts on 195419641974, & 2004.)


1984 Hugo Winner

1984 brought us crack-cocaine, minivans, and the discovery of the AIDS virus. Kathryn Sullivan became the first woman to walk in space, Apple’s Mac PC was released to the technomasses, while The Karate Kid, Sixteen Candles, The Terminator, Ghostbusters, The NeverEnding Story, and This is Spinal Tap! transformed 80’s pop culture.

And David Brin’s Startide Rising won the 1984 Hugo Award for Best Novel!

The other 1984 Best Novel Hugo finalists in ranked order (most to least votes):






How I would have voted:

5. Moreta: Dragonlady of Pern by Anne McCaffrey

Sorry, McCaffrey fans, I just don’t dig this space dragon series. And the constant nominations of books like this make me think the Hugo Awards should add a Juvenile/YA category. I get that it captured the hearts and minds of children, but it doesn’t belong in this grouping.

4. Millenium by John Varley

It took a few chapters before I finally warmed to this intriguing premise with strange characterization. Time travel is used to rescue (read: kidnap) plane crash victims in order to repopulate humanity in the very distant future. And the female protag is voiced like Robert Heinlein… which is so discomfiting.

3. Startide Rising by David Brin

Again, the Hugos need a kiddie category. This space opera about uplifted dolphins and chimps put me off at first, but David Brin turns this potentially silly tale into a dramatic endeavor with cutting conflict and insights about humanity. It’s no surprise it won the Hugo, but it’s not my favorite.

2. Tea with the Black Dragon by R. A. McAvoy

I loved this quirky romantic thriller about a  middle-aged woman searching for her kidnapped adult daughter and the mysterious man who offers to help, although he claims he’s a thousand-year-old dragon. It has some of the funnest dialogue I’ve read in a while, but I’m surprised the Hugo voters embraced this novel’s style, which is almost too mainstream to be labelled SF.

1. Robots of Dawn (#3 of Robot series) by Isaac Asimov

Maybe I’m a pushover for androids (I am), but I loved this Asimov series, and I’m surprised this one was ranked so low by Hugo voters. I can only guess that many voters didn’t read the entire series, which might make this book seem weird and disjointed. In this novel, we see Asimov’s stiff 1950’s protagonist achieve 1980’s enlightenment!

Check back tomorrow to review the 1994 Hugos! 

2 thoughts on “Let’s Go To the Hugos: 1984!

  1. […] up: 20 years ago! (See my previous posts on 1954, 1964, 1974, 1984 & […]


  2. […] I did a little recap of the past Hugo nominees from the years ending in -4: 1954, 1964, 1974, 1984, 1994, & 2004. Ranking books is much easier than rating books, especially when my opinions vary […]


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s