BSFA Shortlist Review: Cuckoo Song by Francis Hardinge

cuckoosongTitle: Cuckoo Song by Frances Hardinge

Setting: post-WWI English village

Summary: 11-year-old Triss wakes up in bed after a mishap she cannot remember. She barely recognizes her family, or her home, and she always feels hungry. Her little sister Penny knows more than she’s letting on, and her parents are receiving strange letters that they won’t talk about. Triss needs to solve this mystery to make things normal again. But were things ever normal?

Flavor quote:

’I…I don’t…’ Triss trailed off helplessly. She didn’t know what she didn’t, but she was frightened by how much she didn’t. [2]

The blurb that was never blurbed:

Münchausen syndrome by changeling proxy.

How it feels: Roomy and light, as middle-grade fiction should be, dappled with eerie aesthetics. Feisty little sister relieves the tension with humor. Dysfunctional family insight from the POV of an unaware insider. At times, less hand-holdy than some adult novels.

How it does not feel: The blurbs make it sound like a horror story. Might be scary for very young children, but everyone else gets the green light to read this at night.

How it does not feel, part 2: Without the occasional references to car cranking, wristwatch history, and displacement of the war-time female workforce, it’s easy to mistake this for a more recent time period.

Supplemental use: Could be useful with young kids suspected of a binge eating disorder. Multiple descriptions of relentless hunger and unsated void-filling might get them talking.

But let’s be serious: It’s cute, but inferior to the rich and sophisticated adult fiction that populates this shortlist.

Should you read this? Your little niece or nephew should read this, while you read The Race. Then you can have a nice chat over scones about the importance of psychological and feminist aspects in speculative fiction. (Both The Race and Cuckoo Song do a fine job of this without reducing feminism to a marketing point.)

*************************************************************************************************************

This review is part of an 8-part review series on the 2014 British Science Fiction Association Best Novel Shortlist. The winner will be announced at the BSFA ceremony at Eastercon on Sunday, April 5.

Previous BSFA Shortlist Reviews:
Europe in Autumn by David Hutchinson
The Race by Nina Allan

Upcoming BSFA Shortlist Review:
The Moon King by Neil Williamson

Advertisements

14 thoughts on “BSFA Shortlist Review: Cuckoo Song by Francis Hardinge

  1. That’s sad. The setting sounds right up my alley. Boo.

    Like

  2. thebookgator says:

    Ah, thanks for your sacrifice. I like what Hardinge does and how she uses language but wasn’t sure about this one. Won’t shortlist it.

    Like

    • fromcouchtomoon says:

      It was no sacrifice at all, just cotton candy. It was a sweet and pleasant kid’s book that I read in a matter of four hours. It was cute, quirky, and it has lots of positive reviews. But it definitely doesn’t belong among the ranks of Nina Allan, Dave Hutchinson, and Simon Ings, though.

      Liked by 1 person

  3. And yet another mention of The Race piles onto the force bearing down upon me and saying BUY THE FUCKING BOOK ALREADY. Are all your reviews really about The Race, in disguise as reviews for other books?

    Like

  4. […] BSFA Shortlist Reviews: Europe in Autumn by David Hutchinson The Race by Nina Allan Cuckoo Song by Francis Hardinge The Moon King by Neil […]

    Like

  5. […] BFSA Shortlist Reviews: Europe in Autumn by David Hutchinson The Race by Nina Allan Cuckoo Song by Francis Hardinge The Moon King by Neil Williamson Lagoon by Nnedi […]

    Like

  6. […] BSFA Shortlist Reviews: Europe in Autumn by David Hutchinson The Race by Nina Allan Cuckoo Song by Francis Hardinge The Moon King by Neil Williamson Lagoon by Nnedi Okorafor Ancillary […]

    Like

  7. […] BSFA Shortlist Reviews: Europe in Autumn by David Hutchinson The Race by Nina Allan Cuckoo Song by Francis Hardinge The Moon King by Neil Williamson Lagoon by Nnedi Okorafor Ancillary […]

    Like

  8. […] Egg ranks as one of the youngest novels I’ve read this year, notwithstanding the similarly named Cuckoo Song (2014) by Francis Hardinge. And like Cuckoo Song, Cuckoo’s Egg employs quite a lot of darling […]

    Like

  9. […] when it comes to finding fantasy I like and what everyone else likes. Francis Hardinge’s Cuckoo Song won the Robert Holdstock Award, but I read it for the BSFA shortlist and it just wasn’t […]

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s