[Book Review] Dreams Before the Start of Time by Anne Charnock

For seekers of a quiet future–away from watching the US government antagonize and bomb other places to bits–Anne Charnock’s latest novel brings a kind of serenity to near future Western life by focusing on the not-so-nuclear… family. In three parts, from 2034 to 2084 to 2120, Dreams Before the Start of Time examines on-the-horizon socio-industrial advances and their implications on some of the most important parts of daily life: romance, family, and childbearing.

LOVE the cover! Throwback colors, gender neutral design, and quite SF-y.

Picking up from her previous novel, the subtle and smoldering Sleeping Embers of an Ordinary Mind, the Toni strand (my favorite strand) continues its trajectory into the next century, as we get to see Toni the teen emerge into adulthood as she encounters ever-evolving approaches to family systems. Cushioned by semi-connected, tangential stories of family, friends, and barley-linked strangers as they pursue various gestational options, Toni’s life is the guidepost for the story, but far from being the only thing going on.

Scientific advances like artificial insemination, unplanned pregnancy, external wombs, sperm donation, and parthenogenesis spawn branches of possibilities for each succeeding generation, while human choices impact family design, establishing unusual, nontraditional systems: siblings as co-parents, boyfriend as godfather, natural father as absentee father, romantic suitor as psychological profile match. While still leaning more toward the cis-hetero side of the spectrum, characters with ace, nonbinary, and open lifestyles are included (though, this is less a story about romance, and more a story about alienation, so be aware that no lifestyle is necessarily promoted). Each variation of family life brings its own benefits, disadvantages, and neuroses, as families are wont to do.

Charnock’s novels are chattier than I normally like, but it’s a different kind of chatty, where empty words host all kinds of subtext, nontext, and unsaid things. While I love all this subtext, this is where I think Charnock’s novels lose favor with pop-SF audiences: by capturing the quotidian in this way, it might be all that some people see. Her depictions are holistic, atmospheric, forest instead of trees; not something popular SF writers are encouraged to do. With Charnock’s work, the best advice is to take nothing at face value.

Along those lines, like any story about birth, this is also a tale about death. The tragic loss of Toni’s mother from the previous novel haunts Toni’s life, influencing her decisions, her fear of commitment, her stubborn practicality, and even how she approaches adventures at the sunset end of her own life. It’s not only about family, but social influence, even from beyond the grave. Because of that specter of death, this is a novel that ends with a genuine poignancy that is often absent in SF—especially when the story is predicated on technological advances—but Charnock’s interest is always in the human aspect first: her characters are real, living, breathing individuals; lost in some ways, directive in others.

With Dreams Before the Start of Time already on my Best SF of 2017 list, Anne Charnock is now solidified as one of my favorite SF authors. I’ve previously criticized awards programs and sci-fi fandom for ignoring her work, and I hope this novel, being more direct in theme than her last, won’t suffer the same fate. Passing over Charnock’s work is negligent, plain and simple.

As a side note, reading this novel reminded me of a wonderful chat between Anne Charnock and Nina Allan last year. Being a reader who is weary of a publishing climate that encourages hefty plotting and contrivance, it’s refreshing to see two SF writers surrender to the organic and human process of thoughts-to-words, and allow their instincts to shape those thoughts into something remarkable and transcendent.


I received this book as an Advanced Review Copy in exchange for an honest review (…which is an arrangement I have actually never agreed to before because it has always smelled a bit funny to me when both sides of the arrangement benefit from positive reviews and sales, but I broke my resolve this time because I’m frustrated by the lack of attention Charnock gets, and I don’t know her well enough to feel compromised). It’s also fair to mention that my Sleeping Embers review is blurbed in the blurb pages of this novel.

Dreams Before the Start of Time comes out today, Tuesday, April 18, 2017. Audiobook, too.


And congrats to my good friend and fellow Exegesis combat vet, Gray Cope (@copygram13) of Who’s Dreaming Who, for winning my Guess the ARC contest! If he isn’t already, he’ll soon regret the weird psi vibes I’ve been sending him all day.

9 thoughts on “[Book Review] Dreams Before the Start of Time by Anne Charnock

  1. graycope14 says:

    You might want to market those “weird psi vibes” because you cured my cold today. Thank you!

    p.s. Nice review. Your point about “subtext, nontext, and unsaid things” is excellent. And how skillfully does Charnock write characters!?! Aside from the exploration of future-conception and child rearing, it was the characters that stood out for me. Your enthusiasm, as well as your words, has made me want to pick up both ‘Sleeping Embers’ and ‘A Calculated Life’. Here’s to championing authors who deserve more recognition.

    Liked by 2 people

  2. PhilRM says:

    Barley-linked strangers are the best kind!

    I was slightly disappointed in ‘Sleeping Embers’: while the individual sections were excellent, I thought that the connections between them were a little too tenuous for it to really work as a novel. It did convince me to read more of Charnock’s work, though, and I’ll certainly give this one a read. (I still have her ‘A Calculated Life’ in my TBR pile.)


  3. They are the best kind!

    Funny that the tenuous connections didn’t impress you; I think that’s what I loved most of all because it emphasized how widespread and insidious the suppression of women’s work has been (and will continue to be). If the connections between threads had been more strongly drawn, it would have narrowed the scope of the message, and wouldn’t have been as powerful.


    • And, hi, Phil! Thanks for commenting over here! I’m loving your contributions to the Shadow Clarke Project!


      • PhilRM says:

        Hi Megan! Glad you’re enjoying them. I’ve certainly enjoyed reading all the Sharke reviews; I hope the actual Clarke shortlist turns out to be half as interesting as some of the Sharke lists.


    • PhilRM says:

      I’ll have to brood over that (brooding is something I excel at). It’s definitely a novel deserving of a re-read.


  4. […] reading fellow blogger Megan AM’s glowing review on her website, I’m left feeling that I missed something. Time permitting; I want to give this […]


  5. […] get this feeling there’s more around the edges of the lives of these fairly privileged people. I reviewed this novel a long time ago, but I think I still feel the same way about it. Some members of the Clarke Shadow Panel have some […]


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s